Scott and Becky Benninghoff and their two daughters, Diana and Cara, came to Fort Wayne from Jacksonville, North Carolina, so that Scott can begin his first year at Concordia Theological Seminary. All are lifelong Lutherans and have experienced an array of LCMS churches over their lifetimes. They are glad to be joining the family of believers at Holy Cross.
Scott was born in Hammond, Indiana in June of 1979 to a steel mill worker and his bride. He attended St. Paul’s Lutheran School in Munster, Indiana from kindergarten through 8th grade before attending public high school at Donald E. Gavit High School. After graduating from Gavit, Scott attended Northwestern University and majored in political science with a minor in history. Having completed Officer Candidates School during his undergraduate summers, Scott was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Marine Corps upon graduating from Northwestern in June 2001. He served as a ground logistics officer for the next 25 years, retiring in July 2026. While on active duty, he attended nine Lutheran churches on each coast, California, Louisiana, and the Carolinas, as well as multiple churches throughout Virginia. He has served as an elder, a congregational president and vice president, choir member, and youth leader. He is excited to learn and grow while serving at Holy Cross.
Becky was born outside of Dayton, Ohio but spent most of her childhood in Appleton, Wisconsin. She and Scott met while at Northwestern where she was pursuing a degree in secondary education. She taught high school math in Wisconsin for a year after graduation while waiting to marry Scott. She then taught in both North and South Carolina until Diana was born. Becky was a stay-at-home mom until she was volunteered to start accompanying one of the small Southeastern District Lutheran churches they were attending. While starting as a girl who took piano lessons as a kid, she transitioned to the organ rather quickly and has been accompanying churches at each Marine Corps stop ever since. She is also the financial administrator and independent media consultant for one of their previous churches in Virginia. She also returned to teaching as a long-term substitute math teacher at Lejeune High School before moving to Fort Wayne.
Diana and Cara are both good Marine kids. They have lived in 11 locations in their 19 and 16 years of life, and yet each time, they make good friends and continue to do well in school and extracurricular activities. Both love to dance. Diana is a sports fan. Cara loves music and the arts. Diana is a sophomore at the University of Pittsburgh, pursuing a degree in athletic training. Cara is a junior at Concordia Lutheran High School where she enjoys singing in the choir and performing in the school plays.